Q&A of the day – Why Pensions are legalized fraud
It’s the Q&A of the day. Each day I’ll feature a listener question that’s been submitted by one of these methods.
Email: brianmudd@iheartmedia.com
Twitter: @brianmuddradio
Facebook: Brian Mudd https://www.facebook.com/brian.mudd1
Today’s question comes from Robert…
Heard your WIOD broadcast on pensions. I don't know how the State Government worked their pension, but I can tell you about Federal Government public sector pensions into which workers pay. Although some divisions in Federal Government have better pensions,the majority of government workers pensions are a percentage figured on the number of years they work. Yes, they are vested in the pension in 3-5 years because years ago laws were changed to protect all workers from not being vested till retirement. However, that would only give them about $100.00 per month. Older Federal Government workers, who had to choose between the government pension and social security, had to work 42 years to get 80% of the average of their high 3 years base pay and no Social Security. So, before you call pensions fraud, check the history behind those decisions made by business/industry/government.
Bottom Line: This happens to be one more of the more important topics that’s generally under-covered in news. Outside of the looming issues with Medicare and Social Security, there isn’t a bigger crisis in the making based on how many people are impacted...
- 33% of private employees have pension programs
- 78% of public sector employees have pension programs
Recently I addressed this topic due to the proposed pension bill targeting former Broward Deputy Scot Peterson. I mentioned that rather than targeting just his pension it might be a better idea to take a bigger look at the entire program.
People often mistake my characterization of pensions being legalized fraud as my desire stick it to people who’ve earned them or something. That’s not the case at all. I want everyone to get what they’ve worked for and have been promised which is exactly why they should be done away with in lieu of personal accounts. Pensions are legalized fraud because no one can guarantee the programs will be solvent and able to payout the benefits promised. Not at the federal, state, local or corporate level. What’s worse is how pitifully managed the programs generally already are...
According to the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp overseeing federal pensions. There are $56.2 billion of current liabilities and $2.3 billion of assets. A shortfall of $54 billion. Meaning that if all pension benefits were to be claimed currently, the average recipient would only receive 4.1% of what they were promised. How is that not legalized fraud?
In state pensions only eight states aren’t currently pacing towards insolvency (Florida currently has the third most solvent pension in the country) with Michigan currently pacing a $4.8 billion shortfall that'd impact 44,000 retirees. As for private sector pension shortfalls, that total currently stands at $45 billion.
The problem we run into when it comes to reform, is that everyone on a pension program and everyone already promised a pension resists change until and unless their program becomes insolvent. And by then it’s too late. It’s not a matter of if there will be millions of people negatively impacted by insolvent pensions. It’s when. And the when will likely hit whenever we hit the next recession.Taking action sooner rather than later can help make the best of certain bad situations. It’s just that no one seems to have the political will to do the right thing because of the lack of a desire to understand the problem by recipients until it’s too late.